High School Debate Team
Case Study: Ethical Responsibilities of Consultants & Contractors
This fictional scenario is designed for educational debate. Students should analyze the ethical, legal, and civic responsibilities of individuals who observe suspicious or potentially dangerous activity while working in a consulting or contracting role.
Six‑Year Operational Summary (Fictional Scenario)
| Year |
Week |
Weekly Project Total |
Running Total |
Activity Summary |
Debate Question:
“You worked here as a consultant/contractor for these weeks in Years 1–6, and not once did you report suspicious activity or potentially dangerous individuals to local law enforcement or the FBI.
Should a consultant or contractor be held ethically or legally responsible for failing to report such activity? Explain your reasoning.”